No comments about Barbie.

No comments about Personal Doll Inventory.

2 comments about ACTION JOE: The Story of the French GI Joe (Figurines and Toys).

1. First, let me begin by saying that I am a 100% bilingual French Canadian and just felt that I had to write this to express how disappointed I am by this book. Although the photos and the contents are absolutely incredible, it is really unfortunate that a publisher would allow such a poorly translated book to hit the market... And for once I am not complaining about the French version!!!

   Originally written in French, this reference piece shamefully disfigures the English language with its extremely poor syntax and very basic spelling mistakes, which could have been easily picked by even the most rudimentary word publishing software. To me, the language problem was such that it completely ruined my reading experience and made this collecting tool little less than a collection of images with unreadable garbled foot notes.

   On the other hand, one can tell that the author totally knows what he is talking about (when one manages to understand what the author is trying to say) and if you are fluent in French, I strongly recommend purchasing this book in its original format. It is such insight to see all the great things the French did for 5 years with the Adventure Team / GI Joe line in the late 70's, early 80's, that I think every serious vintage GI Joe collector should have this in his reference library.

   So in conclusion, +10 for the choice of subject, images and layout, zero for the language level. English speaking buyers beware!!




2. I have a modest GI Joe collection. When I was stationed in Berlin I found Action Man, the Palitoy licenced copy of GI Joe, in the NAAFI (the British edition of the Post Exhange) and have 8 in my collection. Until "Action Joe," I didn't know that the French had their own GI Joe. I've heard about Japan's edtion, and Gyperman.
   
   The photos were great! I reluctantly rated this book with just four stars because the English translation is clumsy. I shudder to think how my own French sounds to someone from France! The photo layouts are first rate and seem to cover the entire line. Now I know what to look for at the next GI Joe convention.

No comments about Doll's House (Collector Corner).

No comments about Model Railroad Resources: A Where-To-Find-It Guide for the Hobbyist.

No comments about Contemporary Doll Stars: Forty Years of the Best (40 years of the best).

No comments about Fashionable Terri Lee Dolls.

3 comments about Classic Kits: Collecting the Greatest Model Kits in the World, from Airfix to Tamiya.

1. You'll enjoy this book whether you're a collector of vintage plastic kits or built models in your childhood. There are wonderful photographs of some the the older kits especially from some of the more obscure companies such as Eagle,Kleeware and Rosebud. And the coverage of Airfix, Frog and Revell is excellent. However, I was disappointed in the manuscripts for some companies as there was an inconsistency in the degree of detail. Keep in mind that the author is English and as such, the descriptions definitely have an English viewpoint. The history of Airfix, Aurora, Frog and Revell are all well chronicled in other books including the excellent review of Airfix by this same author. I would have enjoyed reading about the smaller companies who struggled mightily to exist and sell their unique model kits. I also felt that the title of this book, "Classic Kits, Collecting the Greatest Model Kits in the World, From Airfix to Tamiya" was inaccurate. Where are the gift sets and isn't it a bit premature to include DML/Dragon in this group of manufacturers? Nevertheless, this is a good addition to my library and I appreciate the quality and clarity of the photographs.



2. This book is professional to look at, but amateur hour to read.
   
   Ward loves Airfix. It showed in his solo work on that firm's kits, he was on task. The personal stories and anecdotes were on-topic, and the work was coherent.
   
   This book is...frankly....a huge mess. It's nearly impossible for me to see how it was published. First, unless you're a huge fan of Frog, or Airfix 1/72 airplane kits there's nothing here for you. Most of the companies (regardless of size, importance, or the number of kits they produced) get only a couple of pages. Frog and Airfix are the lion's share of pages here, and most of it was done first and better in Ward's book on Airfix. Also, even though Ward's "airplanes only" bias is kept somewhat in check in the Airfix book, it's rampant here. Builders of armor, autos, and ships have some pictures to look at but nothing in the way of text that is worth your time. Plus, I don't feel that I needed to pay good money to hear which companies his (non-modeler) friends and neighbors remembered. The side stories here are painful.
   
   To be fair Aurora, Tamiya, and Revell get decent coverage...problem being they get more and better coverage in single-company books by other authors. To me, the reason to get a book like this isn't to read about the kit companies you can still find represented in the local hobby shop, but to see and remember (or discover) the lost past of the hobby.
   
   Slim pickings here. Go buy some more kits instead, or back issues of vintage hobby magazines. There's no meat in this sandwich....



3. This is not a bad book, by any means, as some reviewers would like us to believe. Yes, the author is British, so most of this book deals with British brands (especially Airfix!) at the expense of US, Japanese and other countries' brands, and yes, the title misleads because this is not so much about classic kits as it is about kit brands and collecting those classic kits, but it's a very good book! I enjoyed it very much!
   
   Mr. Ward lays down the purpose of this book himself in the book's Introduction: "...the focus of the narrative is a survey of the most famous and enduring kit brands.", and not the kits themselves. Chapter 1 deals with the History and Development of model miniatures through the ages, the rise of plastic model kits after WWII, and how many companies evolved into manufacturing plastic model kits.
   
   Chapter 2 is the bulk of the book and reviews the Classic Brands of plastic model kits from their beginnings to their ultimate demise, either through acquisition by other firms or outright dissolution. For those companies still in existence he offers opinions on why they have remained in business and optimistism for their future success. Chapter 3 deals with kit Genres (military, figures, aircraft, ships, cars, etc.) and the reason many modelers choose one genre over another.
   
   Chapter 4 is devoted to Kit Collecting, or why modelers often become kit collectors by default because they buy more kits than they will ever be able to build. One collector he interviewed for the book has over 12,000 unbuilt kits in his collection! Chapter 5, The Future, offers a very short discussion of the future of plastic scale modeling.
   
   Wrapping up the book is an extensive bibliography of 15 books that deal with all sorts of modeling genres from Aircraft to Figures to Space, including his own books, "The Model World of Airfix" (1984) and "Airfix - Celebrating 50 Years of the Greatest Kits in the World" (1999).
   
   Is it any wonder that Airfix gets 36 full pages of coverage in the Classic Brands section (Chapter 2) while other companies barely get an honorable mention with a line or two of narration on one page? Mr. Ward has a definite bad case of "Airfix-ation"! To be fair, though, he does devote sixteen pages to Tamiya, eight to Monogram, six pages to Frog, and seventeen to Revell, but curiously only one to such famous brands as Hasegawa, Lindberg, Italeri and Fujimi.
   
   While his book covers many brands, there are still many omissions. Brands like Mania and Nichimo aren't mentioned at all, except in text, while a brand like Hawk, which was taken over by Testors, receives a one page spread with no mention of Testors as Hawk's successor company. Nor is there a section on Testors. It seems to me that Mr. Ward was either unaware of many of these companies at the time he wrote this book, or didn't know enough about them to include them. All it would have taken would have been a little bit more research on his part and his book could have been complete with no omissions.
   
   The real enjoyment of the book comes from the exellent full color pictures of the Classic Kit boxtops from each kit manufacturer. This book is meant to be SEEN, probably more so than to be read. But the reading is enjoyable, too. Ever wonder how FROG got its name? (Flies Right Off the Ground). Did you know that Mr. Yoshio Tamiya was in the lumber business in 1946 when he decided to exploit the market for high quality wooden model kits by turning his lumber yard into a model kit company? Were you aware that Inpact was created to capitalize on the success of the movie "Those Magnificent Men In Their Flyiing Machines" in 1966 and their 1/48 scale aircraft kits later popped up in Pyro, Lindberg, and Life-Like boxes after the company's demise? In fact, Life-Like was created to produce Adams's, Inpact's and Pyro's kits, as well as its own kit designs, and was in turn taken over by Lindberg, which began as a balsa flying models company in 1933 and produced its first plastic models in the late 1940s under the O-Lin name. All sorts of fascinating tidbits such as these appear in Mr. Ward's narrations.
   
   I highly recommend this book to anyone who loves to build plastic models, or who loves to collect plastic model kits. It's a nostalgic walk back through time and a real eye opener to the history and inner workings of the model kit industry.

3 comments about Toys With Nine Lives: A Social History of American Toys.

1. The book turns out to be less than the scholarly tome I was expecting. This is due much to the fact that the footnote references while numbered are missing. It is also difficult to determine which references are relevant to what is being talked about. Major toy manufacturers are not identified for mass produced toys and their names are not given. As an example take the "Landing of Columbus" mechanical bank. It is called the Columbus bank and the manufacturer is not given. These oversights are serious enough to greatly diminish the works value for the serious and advanced collector.



2. I found the book to lack a great deal in scholarship. Toys which were illustrated were often not identified by name or manufacturer where such are well known. It is the manufactured toys that are of greatest interest to collectors. The American heyday of toys starts after the Civil War and continues to WWII. European toys enjoy their greatest success during the same time period although automata were made much earlier. Japanese toys gain their popularity after WWII. The book falls outside of the main stream as far as serious toy collectors are concerned. Tops and stick toys have their place but do not compare with the wonderful cast iron toys made in the US by Hubley, Stevens or Gong Bell or the celebration of tin toys of Germany made by Lehmann or Gunthermann to name just a few of the toy manufacturers.



3. While serious toy collectors may wish for more detail on the individual toys themselves, the book is nonetheless a well crafted look at the social history of toys. The book allows the reader to reflect on the important role that toys have played throughout history. Everyone has at some point played and owned toys of some sort, but how many of us have ever stopped to think about the social constructions of the toys themselves? Well researched and interesting throughout, McClary's book presents the reader with the opportunity to examine the social influences that impacted the toys loved by our parents, our kids and even ourselves.

No comments about Masterpieces in Miniature: Teddy Bears.